Compared to warcraft, sarcraft is supposed to have a more realistic and gritty look.
Supposed to? When was this established. Oh right that entire argument that the game has to be smeared in sludge and nothing is ever "bad ass" enough to be "realistic or gritty" is based on the perception of blurry sprites in a 2 day game made 10 years ago.
Also, warcraft's cartoonish look is merely an excuse for the fact that a 3-D engine cannot render realistic units because its just so difficult to work with polygones. Starcraft II is also suffering from this, as we can see.
I'm pretty sure Warcraft got it's cartoony graphics from Warcraft II you know with it's bright colors and exaggerated features.
No Starcraft suffers from the fact the game isn't trying to be like Company of Heroes where each unit looks good, except no one plays the game because it sucks hard. Starcraft II doesn't have the greatest game engine in the world, but neither did Starcraft. I'd rather have a slightly technologicaly impaired engine that can support multiple players with a 200 unit cap and play with thousands of people over the internet, unlike newer games which have a handicapped unit count and no one plays.
It hasn't created anything close to being "cartoony", that is a problem with people having not enough to be angry or miserable about so they have to take it out on Starcraft II. Everyone also says the game is to bright and not gritty enough, but they must have Alzheimer's because take a carefully look at star craft, it is extremely bright. It oozes lots of colors.
So Karune can say whatever he want about units not being in their final version, but it is likely that we'll end up with something very similar to this, which is a clear departur from starcraft's traditional art.
So how much more founded do I need to be? Do you really want to argue that this new ultralisk is realistic-looking an work as well as the original?
well actually I was originally referring to the quote
"The crest is too high, the arms to thick -it also got 4 arms- and the legs too small"
But I forgot you're a professor of alien physiology.